The GOP: A National Party no more… and what I hope we will do about it.
Washington, D.C. (rightcommentary.com): I believe that the GOP is coming unhinged - for lack of a better description. I have never once been this frustrated with my party as I have been in the last 8 years. As I’ve said to colleagues for about the last two years - it takes guts to be a Republican partisan lately. Guts and a lot of stupidity (apparently).
For lack of a better description, Republicans have had a solemn “contract” with the American people. It defined our party, our policies, and our approaches. It comprised the “negative heuristic” of the things we, as partisans, would not do. That contract, as I see it, is roughly comprised of these elements:
- We believe that our fellow citizens are ultimately “good” and capable of accepting responsibility and rewards for their own actions: We are first and foremost committed to seeing individuals have equal access, but not necessarily equal results. We believe government has a purposive place in people’s lives, however, it is not “up to the government” to ensure everyone lives “happily ever after.”
- We believe in limited government because it robs individuals of opportunity: We believe that whatever resources the government takes away, through appropriation and spending, means that much less resource available for the individual. This is detrimental because the market forces that act upon individuals is much more efficient than collective allocations of wealth through government action.
- We are more adept in the realm of foreign policy than our adversaries: We end wars, not start them. We use force when its necessary - decisively - and with clear purpose. We fight when it is only vital to the national interest. We maintain our military so that we can use it when we need it. We are strong in the face of adversity. We protect the weak when they ASK us - for those who are oppressed wanting to be free. We hold our heads high and the flag higher.
- We have high standards and expectations of ourselves and for the nation. Since personal accountability is a key element in our values, we expect that by giving individuals greater access to wealth and opportunity, they will capitalize on it versus squander it. We create opportunities for success - not protect people against failure. We want an equal playing field for everyone to achieve their goals.
- We attempt to live moral, just, lives and encourage others to do the same. We are accountable to God, our family, and our friends.
Those are the five elements of the contract we have with the American people. And how well have we done with executing those elements? In the past eight years? We have been TERRIBLE. There is no distinguishing our behavior from the Democrats:
- We taxed and spent in the last 8 years at a pace (even if you take out war spending) that even would have made the Congress of Tip O’Neil proud.
- We doubled the total number social welfare programs.
- We enlarged social welfare spending by a factor of three.
- We promoted giving tax breaks to people who didn’t pay taxes!
- We created the largest social welfare program (the prescription drug plan) ever created. It costs so much - we have no idea how much it is ultimately going to cost!
- We got into two wars - and finished neither.
- We reduced the size of our military at the time we were fighting two conflicts.
- We created more ill will in the last 8 years than has ever been created.
- We are at risk of falling behind in most of our weapon and intelligence capabilities.
- Our GDP may be surpassed by our competitors.
- Our adversaries hold a stranglehold on our finances, our labor, and our wealth.
- Our party leaders have acted like drunken sailors and have tolerated immoral and criminal activity within our partisan ranks. We had Abramoff, Foley, Hastert, Stevens, and of course - Sen. “Footsie” - Larry Craig. Of course, the latest, Rep. Vito J. Fossella’s getting busted driving drunk and then admitting he fathered a love child. You can’t run on family values when you don’t practice them.
- We’ve let the ideology of “stupidity” trump our own logic of how to conduct policymaking.
- We’ve been willing to sell our souls on issues like immigration, welfare, and national defense, for just a few votes more in Congressional races.
- We failed to control spending across the board.
- We deregulated financial markets - with no sense of accountability or oversight.
- The Congress was more than willing to sell it’s soul to the President for what? Financial and foreign policy debacles? We abandoned internal accountability for our values.
- Our fundraising has dried up.
- Our leaders seem clueless - I mean, come on “Change you deserve?” Is that a joke? Oh and by the way - that’s also the logo for an anti-depressant medication. I realize at this point we may all need it as partisans - but this is the best we could do?
- You have Boehner crying on the floor of the Senate.
- We failed to get free trade done.
- We didn’t expand democracy.
- Our international credibility is shot.
- The Public won’t trust us…
- We LOST three Red seats in the House - and we haven’t even gotten to the General yet.
I could continue… but my hand is already cramping. Suffice to say - between Mr. Bush and the Republicans in Congress - the last 8 years have been “I can out democrat the Democrats!”
And now - just now - are we finally getting an inkling that perhaps the voters are ticked… I mean - it didn’t occur to anyone in 2006 when we got pummeled - despite the “Grand Architect’s” vision for victory. It didn’t occur to anyone that perhaps things were screwed up in the 2004 election. Oh no - we took our narrow victory as a sign for a “mandate from the people” to keep marching down the idiotic path of stupidity we’ve been in since then.
The consequence of all of this is simple - we’re going to lose at least 25 seats in the House - probably 30. Who knows - maybe even more. We’re going to lose at least 4 maybe 6 or more seats in the Senate. The next President will face solidly Democrat controlled houses. Moreover, we can expect this pattern to be repeated probably across the country in terms of Governors and state races.
Peggy Noonan said the President has destroyed the Republican Brand. Well - he wasn’t the only one - but the brand definitely is in BAD shape. The worst perhaps since Taft.
The voters have NO REASON TO PLACE THEIR FAITH IN US ANYMORE! We have breached every tenant of the compact.
If we have any HOPE of ever reclaiming our high ground, I am deeply hoping that Republicans collectively think about the following:
- Our VALUES matter. Conservatism MATTERS. Stand up for those values. We are slammed on race issues because apparently we don’t remember our values of equality. We’re slammed on economic issues because we decide welfare is better than making markets work. We’re slammed on minority issues because we protect businesses that want to exploit workers versus demanding responsibility and accountability across the board. We’re more than willing to give American wealth away without asking for anything in return? Enough.
- Stop the stupid gimmicks and giveways in welfare. Stop the crazy-drunken spending! PERIOD! JUST STOP! Tax holidays? Great - more borrowing… less money in the private sector. Rebates? Great - another gimmick. Bail out packages!? great - more borrowing. Prescription drug plans - great more borrowing. No reforms of banking, finance, and business practices - great - more costs for consumers. Bottom line - Republicans are for responsible government - not crazy government that gives lollipops to everyone in the hopes they get re-elected for being a “Republocrat.” Enough.
- No more stupid-crazy wars we haven’t thought through the consequences. We don’t have the military and the resources for this stupidity. Defeat the Taliban in Afghanistan, chase AQ down and kill them, and try and get the Iraqis to stand up. Get serious in Iraq and commit the resources we need or get out and deal with the consequences. Improve our military readiness. Improve our weapons platforms. Expand our military to a proper size so we can “walk and chew gum” at the same time. Hollow threats and stupid conflicts… Enough. Our sons and daughters demand our leadership so that their sacrifice is never in vain.
- Get America self-sufficient in the areas of Finance, Labor, and Energy again. We have lost ground in all of these areas and it will affect our competitiveness. Unless we’re interested in someone else being the top dog - we need to get our people educated better, we need to get our financial house at both the macro and micro level in order, and we need to STOP STOP STOP this massive stupidity about energy policy. As Republicans we need to be honest with the American people - if we don’t have cheap energy, you will suffer. Any policy that punishes energy inputs creates misery for Americans. Enough with the Polar bears and scare science. Enough with the “we can be green - see - we’re green - see my green hat!” Get serious about getting a real energy policy that limits US dependence on foreign oil. Get Serious about ensuring we have the energy we need to function. Get serious about improving our labor force and our resource base. ENOUGH! Get serious about this stuff. We have principles and values that speak to these issues - APPLY them.
- Either drop the “moral values” platform or straighten up. Personally, I believe that Republicans need to straighten up and start attracting the talent needed to run the party. Enough with tolerating stupidity and nonsense because we’re worried about “losing a seat.” If a member of our ranks goes astray - then PUNISH HIM. Period. In attempting to keep ONE SEAT at a time - we’ve lost control of Congress. ENOUGH. Be accountable for your actions!
I’m sorry if this seems harsh- but enough. I’ve had it. This isn’t the party I joined and I’m having a hard time getting excited about our party and our chances in November if we’re unwilling to make meaningful changes and return to our key values. Reagan said he didn’t leave the Democratic Party - it left him. Well - that’s how I feel now about Republicans. If we’re going to behave like Democrats and abandon our values and our “partisan faith” than we are a national party no more. It will take 20-30 years for us to recover unless we start right now to get our act together.
I fear it will take a shellacking in November for us to learn this lesson. Look at that MAP up there and tell me why Republicans are not the majority? Tell me WHY we’re on the ropes? I’ll tell you why - because we stopped acting like Republicans and the voters have had it too.
Use this HTML text to share this article with others:
Although I don’t agree wholly with everything Newt’s saying - his article is definitely worth reading….
http://newt.org/tabid/102/articleType/ArticleView/articleId/3393/Default.aspx
Check it out.
Bryan
Trackbacks & Pings:
Audio: Hannity and others call out the GOP | Infidels Are Cool
Fiscal Conservatism Was a Branding Strategy, Nothing More (Good People Bett..
The National Conservative » Blog Archive » The death of an o..
BlueRidgeForum » Congressional Conservatives: Our Last Line of Defens..
The Strata-Sphere » Blog Archive » Another GOP “True C..
GOP “Bloodbath” in November?:
Can the GOP Avoid an Election-Day Disaster? - America’s Election HQ
Mississippi Microcosm Spells Doom For GOP - Donkey Dish
Which Way? Where does the Republican Party go from here? « Crystal C..
race42008.com » Blog Archive » MS-01: Not The Beginning Of ..
Brown Pelican Society Commentary - Post details: GOP Suffers a Crushing Blo..
Conservatives Should Still Have Hope For November
Let Freedom Ring » Blog Archive » Cowards Turn Tail
‘This is the floor; we’re underneath it’ - The Carpetbag..
GOP Stunned By Loss in Mississippi : NFD
Blogbat: Republicans: Doing the Work the DNC Wants to Do
A New GOP Direction is needed now | The GOPNation Blog
Firstfruits Of A Massacre - Hard Starboard
Mississippi chuckling « Ned Raggett Ponders It All
illinoisreview: GOPUSA ILLINOIS Daily Clips - May 15, 2008
The Pink Flamingo :: Mark Levin Betrays the GOP
Could the Libertarians Spoil Alaska for the GOP? - US Presidential race 200..
Conservative Central,is a grassroots blog site,goal keeping Conservative ma..
Democrats Win Conservative Republican District Special House Election For 3..
CalvinDude.com » GOP Gets What It Deserves
Boehner’s ‘New’ GOP Strategy: Same Policies, ‘Refurbished’ Messag..
A CALL TO ACTION « Welcome to GayConservative.org
Big Lizards:Blog:Entry “Mississippi: All Politics Is Loco”
House GOP Caucus splintered : Reagan´s GOP
If the GOP can’t win in Mississippi, they won’t win anywhere! &..
The passion alone speaks about your loyalty–I’ve talked to many Republicans (and Democrats) as this election season simmers. Believe me, there’s plenty of fed up to go around for both parties right now. I’m curious to see what direction the GOP will take–who’s McCain going to pick for VP? And I’m curious to see what the specific platform consists of. With the Dems, I know what the specific platform consists of–more taxes, same old same old. No one has stopped to consider those social programs will expand our expansive debt and are largely unnecessary, if the government were to truly use our resources wisely–getting rid of earmarks, restraining spending, controlling fraud especially in the healthcare expenditures.
I think you’re doing the right thing by speaking up–and you certainly aren’t alone in that regard. This has been a wild and reckless ride, and I figure somebody somewhere needs to get a grip. I’ve found myself wondering–does the GOP have a strategy that’s offensive in the sense of trying to win? Or is the plan to simply deflect the opposition (that would be fatal)?
Kay B. Days last blog post..Why every country needs Amendment I or an equivalent
I saw the link to your EXCELLENT article on GOPHub.com and linked your article to a similar posting on my blog.
We’re in deep trouble come November and I think many of us saw it coming over the last couple of years. Thank you for putting our frustrations into a cohesive, wonderfully detailed essay.
I’ll be back often!
Man, the people are jumping off the Repub ship in droves, many for what you cite in this post. But how many are simply ditching the bandwagon because they aren’t ‘winner’s’ anymore?
People are funny that way.
History shows it is rare for either party to lose Congressional seats in double digits two election years in a row, but I won’t be surprised if it happens. The Republican party hasn’t bottomed out yet and if McCain wins that retards the rebuilding process.
Chris Cs last blog post..Licking Windows #19: Monster Mistake
The problem is one of denial. Not denial by the Republican leadership. It’s denial by the pundits, the wonks and even the conservative base. The Republican Leadership isn’t and hasn’t been anywhere near conservative for many many years. The majority of the Republican Congressional members do not want smaller government. They enjoy their power and want more of it. They do not believe in the philosophy that led to the creation of this nation. There is no other way to explain throwing a winning strategy out the window and refusing to adopt it even after repeatedly shellackings by trying to be Demo lite. I challenge anyone to explain it in any other logical way.
The talking heads on radio pretend that they can’t understand the Rep leadership behavior. They will use such flimsy excuses as: a desire to be liked, a desire for good press, etc. Horse feathers. How much republican appeasement has resulted in increased popularity? None.
The Republican party is becoming the centrist party. (and doing a poor job at that.)
I have more respect for the Dems these days than I do for the Reps. At least with the Dems, I know that they have no intention of obeying the constitution. I know they want a socialist state. After all, they say so. The Rep leadership still trys to give lip service to those yokels back home who believe in freedom and individual liberty. The Rep leaders don’t believe in that stuff any more. It’s power and control.
Conservatives have no choice. They can’t beat city hall. It’s time to start a new Party.
dons last blog post..Congress Repeals Law of Gravity
Bryan I agree with you whole heartedly. You are right, I have said so myself that there is no more distinguishing the Republicans from the Democrats. At one point I suggested dissolving both and establishing two, perhaps three new parties. After all - Independents have been a fairly weak force to reckon with.
Thanks for your support of my blog and the often kind words. I am humbled.
Layla
Layla Elizabeths last blog post..Some Of The “Righteous” Right Are No Better Than Those That Spew The Hate Rhetoric On The Left - Next Time I Will Not Throw You An Olive Branch
Well, Bush’s spending on the war and his social programs has accomplished one thing for you conservatives: the Democrats ability to spend money will be severely hampered for many years to come. Too bad. Of course, he’s ruined the military too, but since the Democrats will inherit that mess, you guys will be able to blame it on them. Ugh.
I can appreciate your call to values. At the same time, though, it seems to me that the Bush administration’s tendency to value ideology over practical realities has confounded its attempts to be effective, especially in Iraq. Whatever happened to good, old-fashioned realpolitik? Example: Our letting Iraqi state-owned factories die, because free-market forces were so all important. How that made sense in a war zone with dissatisfied young people in need of work is beyond me, unless I see it as an example of conservative ideology seeking to impose its vision on the world, instead of being truly conservative and working with what already existed.
I’m thinking of Edmund Burke’s tree metaphor in his Reflections on the French Revolutoin. That for me is real conservatism, not this radical urge to remake other societies or our own.
Mark Stonemans last blog post..Observing Memorial Day
What we need here Bryan is a call for all Reagan conservatives to become delegates to a Conservative Cyber Convention to be held online….something along the lines of what Unity08 tried to do but failed.
By the way, I have come to believe the Republican Party both you and I know and love should more rightly be called the Peoples’ Party.
ex animo
davidfarrar
David Farrars last blog post..How Can We Unite?